If you are a fan of smoked meats, then you have likely considered using either propane or an electric smoker. Both have their pros and cons, but which one is the best for you?
In this blog post, we will break down the differences between propane and electric smokers, so that you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.
Propane Smoker vs. Electric Smoker
Propane and electric smokers are two of the most popular types in use today. They both have features that make them easy to operate while still offering a good performance. They offer a modest budget-friendly price range starting at around $200 up towards higher-end models like the Cuisinart gas smoker.
In the $200-$300 range of electric smokers, you may easily find Masterbuilt, Char-broil, or Dyna-Glo heavy-duty models.
Just like Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker has all the necessary features covering up to $200. Similarly, Dyna-Glo DGU732BDE-D Digital Electric Smoker for just $213 is a wonderful option.
Electric smokers offer amazing temperature control, ease of use, and reliability. The drawbacks are that they need a power source to plug into so make sure you plan for this if your area experiences frequent outages or periods without electricity!
The low-temperature range of electric smokers makes them excellent for cold smoking, but they’re not as versatile when it comes to heating.
Gas-powered units can reach higher temperatures and are far more portable – which means you’ll have options no matter where your adventure takes place!
However, these machines need close monitoring because the target may wander off without warning; some models even fail insulation standards fairly easily.
Propane Smoker Overview
Gas grills use a heat source to cook food at low temperatures, usually between 225F and 250 degrees Fahrenheit. Most importantly they cause wood chips or pellets to burn up in flames which infuses flavor into your meal!
Gas smokers come in handy when there’s no electricity available but plenty of fuel resources available around; especially during camping.
Propane and natural gas are both used to fuel up a gas smoker. The majority use propane tanks as their source; however, some people prefer natural gas-powered units because they can achieve higher temperatures and have more control over their output level.
The propane smoker is a great choice if you want to enjoy delicious food without having any hassle. You only need an external tank that can be found in most stores usually 20 pounds gas tank.
Those who prefer natural gas-powered smokers though will have their hookup installed professionally by someone qualified for the job.
When cooking on an open flame, you’ll find a place for wood chips or pellets above the flame. With little effort from yourself, you can increase or decrease the flame pressure with a knob.
Propane Smoker Pros
- Gas smokers are among the most portable smokers on the market. All you need is a propane tank, and you can place them wherever you want. When going camping, many people prefer propane smokers over electric smokers.
- Talking about the pricing, again a propane smoker is one of the most affordable smokers on the market. However, don’t be fooled by the inexpensive price; they’re still of great quality and make wonderful cuisine.
- Propane smokers have low recurring costs. Propane is generally available, and refilling propane tanks is quite inexpensive. As a result, the continuing expenditures on maintenance are rather cheap.
- Due to their simplicity, propane smokers have few components, they are easy to operate and need little maintenance.
- Propane smokers create richer food! It is usually experienced by many grillers that gas smokers offer a tastier, smokier flavor.
Propane Smoker Cons
- The problem with propane smokers is that they often heat up too fast, giving you less control over the temperature inside your chamber.
- The insulation is also a drawback. Poor insulation results in performance issues during bad weather conditions or when there’s no wind for ventilation.
- These smokers are low-tech in comparison to electric devices, so you may not receive all of the conveniences. Just like Bluetooth connectivity, which you easily find in an electric smoker.
Electric Smoker Overview
Electric smoker works with electricity so to smoke, you need to find a place near the electric board.
This product has a variety of features that make cooking more convenient, enjoyable, and delicious.
Electric smokers use a low temperature to gently cook your food, similar to an oven’s heating element. After that, the heating element heats your smoker by pumping hot air through the cooking chamber.
Many high-end electric smokers include both a water pan and a wood chip tray. This water pan keeps your meat wet while also maintaining the cooking atmosphere.
Before using the smoker it is very important to preheat the grill. So unlike a propane smoker, you need to wait a bit before starting cooking.
The most notable feature is being able to add wood chunks directly into its hopper. In this way, it catches fire which produces smoke within food while maintaining consistent low heat throughout the entire smoking cycle without burning anything!
Electric Smoker Pros
- When compared to other types of smokers available, electric smokers are often the easiest to operate, particularly those with a digital thermostat and control panel. After you’ve started your smoker, you even do other chores while your meat cooks.
- Although electric smokers are slightly more costly than propane smokers, they are rather inexpensive when compared to charcoal smokers or other types of smokers. So overall, they are pocket friendly as they come with more advancement.
- Electric smokers are extremely safe to use since they do not require propane tanks or hazardous gases. As a result, because there is less danger, this smoker is ideal for beginners.
- The temperature control on electric smokers is precision-based, meaning you can cook your food without it overheating. They also work well for cold smoking because of their ability to maintain low levels throughout the process.
- Electric smokers are allowed everywhere even in public places as they are the safest smokers on the planet.
Electric Smoker Cons
- You will need a power outlet anywhere you go with this electric monster.
- An electric smoker does not produce the same high temperatures as a propane smoker, so you will have to compromise on flame.
- When cooking with one of them, you will not easily obtain a smoke ring. Even if you smoke wood for taste, it will not burn hot enough to release the chemicals essential for a smoke ring to be formed.
- Because of the higher-tech nature of electric smokers, repairs can be more costly.
- You cannot use it in rainy weather as there will be a danger of electric shocks.
Which is better? Electric or Propane Smoker?
When purchasing a smoker, there are several variables to consider. We’ll go through the most crucial ones and compare gas and electric versions. Remember that they are all significant, and any one of them might be the determining factor for you.
Overall, a gas smoker is usually cheaper. The cheapest models come with all of the basic features and can be purchased for under $200. However, just watch out if you want high-quality equipment because there’s also plenty within reach at affordable prices too but exceeding $200! Masterbuilt MB20050716 30″ Thermotemp is a strong recommendation.
While it might seem like running an electric smoker would cost more in comparison to propane-based ones due solely to their power source. Take note that this isn’t always true since each type varies depending on where they’re located geographically.
But for sure, you need to pay more to get facilities like Bluetooth connectivity, Wi-Fi, or temperature sensors. Masterbuilt MB20074719 Bluetooth with advanced technologies is a must-have for all-electric smoker lovers!
- Ease of use
An electric smoker is the best choice if you don’t have any know-how of temperature settings because all the temperature settings appear on the unit. You just set your desired temperature then sit back while it does all work out for yourself!
If going entirely gas-powered looks better then take advantage because these smokers get up quickly while also maintaining constant heat which means less waiting around!
Overall, an electric smoker is your best option for convenience and simplicity if you have power in your yard, on your deck, balcony, or patio.
Electric smokers are well-made, simple to use, and dependable. You can smoke food if you have enough electricity.
Gas units might be less dependable, especially if of poor quality. However, because gas smokers are less sophisticated than electric smokers, they may be easier to repair if something goes wrong.
- Extreme weather resistance
The four seasons griller needs to consider how their smoker will perform in bad weather.
With electric smokers, you should worry about the water and electricity mix. For example, if there is any light rain or snow then I would recommend having some cover for your barbecue like a tarp that can be placed over the top of it.
If using gas grills don’t worry nearly as much because they generally aren’t well insulated. These can be used in any weather but of course, the inner temperature would change dramatically so you must keep an eye on it.
Cleaning an electric and propane type is quite comparable and simple, especially when compared to their charcoal counterparts.
The propane machines, on the other hand, maybe a little more difficult to clean. Because of the intense heat, fuel expenditure, and smoke, the fat drips down more than if you used electricity.
- Temperature range
Most electric smokers have a temperature range of 100-275F (38 – 135C). This is perfect for low ‘n’ slow smoking, as it won’t sear or roast meats but will keep them soft and juicy at just below 200 degrees Fahrenheit.
Some gas-powered models can go up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, allowing you to grill some foods on top while still maintaining their original shape!
Best Brands to Buy
Smokers come in all shapes and sizes, but if you want to be able to cook your food with ease then it’s important that the smoker can do what needs to be done.
Here are three well-known brands which produce quality smokers: Masterbuilt, Char-Broil, and Smoke Hollow (for those on a tight budget who still want great results). However, I would recommend checking out Camp Chef too because they have gas models available at lower prices than most other companies!
Final thoughts – which one should you buy?
The right smoker will make your food taste like nothing else, and they’re so easy to use!
There’s only one problem: if you want a unit that doesn’t require much babysitting then go with propane but expect consistency problems when smoking delicate proteins.
On the other hand, electric smokers offer set-and-forget convenience at any time of day. It is perfect for careless BBQ lovers who love to move around while grilling.
Thanks for coming to the easiest site on smoking!
We hope that by now you are convinced of how great it is to have a smoker whether propane or electric.
Keep reading and grilling with “The Best BBQ Site” smokerssnicket